|
Notes
on Posting Links Peeer Review Teams
and Commenting on Websites
When you post a link for a prototype or preview draft of a website
project, please include a paragraph about what you are trying to
accomplish. You can include any questions you may have that you
would like your reviewers to address. This paragraph will help focus
your reviewers.
Prototype reviews will typically be done in class in a small group
setting. If you miss your group meeting, you may make up the review
if you visit your team members’ websites and write comments
within one week of the group meeting. Preview responses
(which are done on the web outside of class) should also be completed
within one week of the preview posting due date.
Here is the seemingly torturous process I would like you to follow
in completing your group review session on prototype webs.
Fire up two computer. Go to our community website.
On both computers: In the peer review team block,
click on a name, then click on view all blog entries.
Now it gets different.
On one computer: click on the website of the
prototype you are discussing.
On the other computer: Start a new comment to
the blog entry that announces the prototype url. I would like all
comments to be done as comments (this will help me keep track of
them). Please type in the names of the people who are there in your
group (this is so I will have a record of who attended and can give
appropriate credit).
Now the author of the site should talk about what he or she is
trying to accomplish, what questions he or she has and what concerns.
As a group talk through these issues, and discuss the prototype.
Use what you have learned from Krug to talk about the site:
1. Use a clear visual hierarchy.
2. Be consistent, use conventions.
3. Break pages into clearly defined areas.
4. Make it obvious what's clickable.
5. Keep the noise down.
Unless the site is very experimental, the first page should tell
you where you are what the site is about and why go on. You should
have clear expectations about where the links will take you and
why you should click them. The organization of the site should be
clear. Click on each of the links that work. Do you know where you
are going? Why you are going there? How to get back? The scribe
should record the highlights of this conversation in the new comment
he or she has started.
Repeat this process for each of the people in your group.
|